Tuesday, December 30, 2014

Phoenix nursery (s)hopping, with mixed results

Today I had reserved time to do some nursery (s)hopping in Phoenix. I’d compiled a list of four nurseries based on information I found online and some general recommendations in gardening forums. While none of them specializes in succulents per se, it was my assumption that they would have a much better selection than what I’m able to find at home in the Sacramento area—and at better prices to boot.

Well, you know what they say about the word “assume:” It makes an “ass” out of “u” and “me.”

The first nursery on my list was Baker Nursery. My visit took exactly zero seconds because, as it turned out, Baker Nursery had gone out of business. I should have checked their website first!

Stop #2 was Moon Valley Nurseries. They have nine locations in the Phoenix area. I went to the Scottsdale one because it was closest to my hotel. If I had picked a different location, my experience probably would have been different and, most likely, vastly better.

It started off well enough. My eyes immediately went to this Agave nickelsiae just outside their main building. It was a beautiful specimen but the price sent me reeling: $249.99 for what looked like a 5-gallon can. Yikes!!

141230_Phoenix_MoonValleyNursery_0001

I walked on towards where the other agaves were when my feet sank into something soft. I looked down. No, it wasn’t wet sand, it was freshly poured concrete! And I had left four or five well-defined footprints.

I must have been cursing because a guy came out to see what the fuss was about. I told him that there needs to be a barrier, or at least clear signage, for people like me who look at the plants and not where they’re going!

141230_Phoenix_MoonValleyNursery_0002

He was very unhappy and went to find the concrete guy so he could smooth out my footprints before the concrete set. I tried to find a way across to the succulents, to no avail, so I eventually gave up and left. My shoes are heavier now than they’d been in the morning thanks to concrete stuck in the soles. Nice souvenir to take home!

Nursery #3 was Whitfill Nursery. They’re a corporate sponsor of the Desert Botanical Garden and have a full-page ad on the back cover of the brochure you get when you visit the garden. Because of that I assumed (here’s that word again) that they would have a large succulent selection.

141230_Phoenix_WhitfillNursery_0001

As you can see, they do have a fairly decent assortment of succulents, especially cacti.

141230_Phoenix_WhitfillNursery_0002

But their prices were not what I would call a bargain—generally $50 for a 5-gallon plant.

141230_Phoenix_WhitfillNursery_0003

I didn’t even bother to check the prices on the boxed specimens.

141230_Phoenix_WhitfillNursery_0006

While Whitfill had some agaves, their selection wasn’t stellar.

141230_Phoenix_WhitfillNursery_0005

Having said that, these Agave titanota did sing a siren song to me but I resisted. Again, I expected better prices considering we’re in Arizona.

141230_Phoenix_WhitfillNursery_0009

Their selection of 1-gallon sized cacti was very disappointed. What you see in the next photo is about all I could find. They were priced at $10 each. Is it just me or does the way they are “presented,” if you can call it that, look particularly loveless?

141230_Phoenix_WhitfillNursery_0010

I left Whitfill after 10 minutes, disappointed and dissatisfied.

My last stop was at Elgin Nursery. My expectations were so low that I didn’t even bother taking my camera into the nursery (the photos below were taken on my cell phone; apologies for the subpar quality).

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0025

But whaddayaknow?! Elgin ended up being the best of the bunch. Like the other nurseries I visited, their focus seems to be on shade trees—especially large boxed specimens—but I was happy to see climate-appropriate shrubs at outstanding prices. Here is a sampling.

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0002

$3.99 for 1-gallon plants and $12.99 for 5-gallon plants? You’d be hard pressed to find a nursery in California that offers prices as good as these, at least in my neck of the woods.

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0023 141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0022

Succulents were priced higher, as is to be expected. Even so, Elgin’s prices beat the other nurseries I’d visited by a good 20%.

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0021

I hadn’t really planned on buying a cactus, but considering that the Mexican fence post (Pachycereus marginatus) is a personal favorite—and that at Elgin you get three stems per pot!—I pulled the trigger.

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0013

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0001

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0019 

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0018 141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0012

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0004

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0020

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0003

I can’t get used to the sight of bare-roots ocotillos being sold by the bundle. It looks like you’re buying dead sticks but apparently they root easily. $29.99 seemed quite reasonable to me. If I lived here, I would have bought some.

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0011

The sale of ocotillos, like many plants native to Arizona, is governed by state law and requires a permit. That’s what the green tags must be.

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0008

So what did I end up buying?

141230_Phoenix_ElginNursery_0024

In addition to the Mexican fence post cactus, I also found a slipper plant (Pedilanthus macrocarpus, blue form) that I‘d been looking for—reasonably priced at $14.99 for a 5-gallon can—and a silver-leaf cassia (Senna phyllodinea) for $3.99. It will made a nice addition to our desert bed.

Tomorrow I’m heading to Tucson, and I’m hoping that nursery shopping will be more rewarding there.

RELATED POST:

2014 Desert Trip index

13 comments:

  1. Well darn! The only one of these I've been to is Elgin and it looks pretty much exactly like I remember it. Before our trip I asked a couple of locals (a blogger and a gardening friend of my brother's) for recommendations and researched online what they'd mentioned before going, thus I didn't bother (succulents seemed like an after thought). Although I must have heard about Elgin from one of them? Anyway good finds!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe you told me about Elgin? I did most of my research last year and I can't remember who recommended what. But going to Elgin was definitely worth it.

      Delete
  2. Just shows why one must never discount a nursery first until they've explored it, nice haul :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Exactly! My experience is that nurseries that look nice and fancy are always more expensive than the plain-looking ones.

      Delete
  3. Wish you had posted asking for recommendations!! Arizona Cactus Sales, Treeland and Summerwinds are usually great nurseries! We are all devastated by Baker's closing their doors, but Berridges is only a mile away...beautiful nursery! A but further out in Queen Creek is Desert Horizons. I never go to Moon Valley, and always tell my clients to avoid them. They are the Walmart of nurseries!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was stooopid not to ask for recommendations from locals. I'll certainly know better next time. I wish I'd gone to Baker's last year when they were still in business.

      Thanks for the other recommendations!

      Delete
  4. I'd have bought that pedilanthus too. I never see the MFP cactus for sale so can't comment on the price, but most of those prices do seem higher than SoCal. Good luck in Tucson!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pedilanthus macrocarpus seems to be more popular than ever. I saw it everywhere in Phoenix and Tucson. It looks great in the ground or in a large container.

      Delete
  5. We have better prices here in California! Wow!

    ReplyDelete
  6. You find so many wonderful bargains when you shop, it was bound to average out at some point with some dud trips. Sorry to hear it, but glad you found one satisfying store. Happy New Year!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I made the mistake of picking out general-purpose nurseries. From now on I'll stick to succulent nurseries :-).

      Delete
  7. How disappointing! I hate leaving nurseries empty-handed - there's always the expectation that there's going to be *something* to buy, whether it's on the wishlist or an unexpected bargain. Come to think of it I hate leaving any shop without buying something... there's always that feeling in the back of my mind that the shop owners think I've stolen something if I just walk out.

    I can't believe how expensive some of those succulents were - they're right next door to their native habitat aren't they?

    ReplyDelete