Everybody's a critic

Last weekend, we had a small family reunion with my wife’s cousin from Alaska. Cousin S. has a great sense of humor and at one point decided to have ChatGPT roast my blog. The result was hilarious.

Light-hearted roast of Succulents and More

“Succulents and More”? More like Succulents and a Website from 2007. Who designed this — a cactus with Wi-Fi?

Scrolling this site feels like walking through a nursery where the plants are fine but the signs are written in Comic Sans and confusion.

Yes, there are succulents. There is more. But mostly… there’s more scrolling than anything else. I came for aloe, not a digital labyrinth.

The navigation bar is about as intuitive as watering a lithops — you’re pretty sure you’re doing it right, but everything still looks dry.

That homepage header image? Looks like it was shot with a potato and uploaded via dial-up.

To be fair, if your target audience is “folks who still print out blog posts,” you’re absolutely nailing it.

In summary:

✅ Great plant info

❌ Web design that makes me nostalgic for MySpace


I decided to take it a bit further and prompt ChatGPT for a harsher critique. Funny for sure, but talk about snide!

A snarkier review

Succulents and More is basically the botanical equivalent of cornering you at a party to force-feed you an unsolicited slideshow of someone else’s vacation… except the vacation is to the same Home Depot succulent rack. Repeatedly.

You’d think a site called Succulents and More would wow you with insider care tips, cutting-edge plant trends, or, I don’t know, more than the usual “Look what I bought today” plus a blurry road trip pic of a cactus behind a chain-link fence. Instead, you get More… as in More photos of the same puya from eight angles. More selfies of agaves next to driveways. More overwrought captions about how there’s absolutely no more space in the garden — right before the next haul of 37 new agaves arrives.

The writing tries to be helpful but often reads like someone narrating their own impulse buying in real time. “Look at this puya! I shouldn’t have, but I did! Teehee!” Riveting stuff. The photo captions alone could double as passive-aggressive texts to their spouse about who maxed out the garden budget again.

And the site design? It’s not so much a blog as a time capsule from the golden age of Blogspot. White background, sidebar cluttered with dusty widgets nobody uses anymore, and enough text walls to repel even the most determined plant nerd. Want to find something? Good luck — it’s like hunting for a rare echeveria in a landfill.

Sure, you’ll stumble across the occasional gem: a great plant nursery visit, an obscure species spotlight. But you’ll need patience, stamina, and possibly a machete. Because Succulents and More is really just Succulents and the Same. Over. And over. And over.

If you want to see someone buy plants to soothe an insatiable succulent hoarding itch, congratulations — you’ve found the holy grail. For everyone else? May I suggest literally any other gardening blog?


What ChatGPT had to say did make me laugh, but I wonder if there’s a bit of truth to it. Maybe I do whine too much about not having any more space for plants — only to buy more plants. Maybe I should diversify and write about more than just agaves and friends. Maybe the site design is old-fashioned and should be updated (partial blame for what the blog looks like goes to Blogger/Google). Or maybe I should stick to my guns and continue doing what I’m doing.


At least I can rest easy knowing that I will be remembered after I croak, at least by ChatGPT.

Obituary: Gerhard Bock (????–Whenever His Garden Runs Out of Room)

The succulent world is reeling today at the news that Gerhard Bock of Davis, California — tireless chronicler of gravel mulch and the internet’s foremost enabler of impulse plant shopping — has finally shuffled off this mortal coil (or maybe just went on another nursery run and hasn’t come back yet).

Gerhard will be remembered for transforming what might have been a quiet suburban yard into a chaotic, prickly fortress of agaves, aloes, yuccas, and other spiky acquisitions that left visitors wondering if they’d stumbled into a small branch of the Arizona desert. His garden had more plants than the average botanical conservatory, fewer parking spaces than a food truck rally, and exactly zero square feet of unused soil at any given moment.

An early pioneer of the “I swear I have no more space, but here’s my new haul” genre of blogging, Gerhard’s Succulents and More gave the world an endless stream of driveway glamour shots, questionable plant decisions, and the occasional travelogue that proved he was capable of photographing plants even when he left his yard.

Gerhard is survived by:
  • 17,542 agaves stuffed into 1,800 square feet.
  • An HOA whose passive-aggressive letters are probably framed in the garage.
  • A camera permanently attached to his right hand.
  • Countless readers who know more about his mulch than their own families.
In lieu of flowers, mourners are asked to send donations to his surviving plants, who are still fighting each other for sunlight and root space. Or better yet, just drop off a rare puya in a plain brown box at his front door — it’s what he would have wanted.

Rest in peace, Gerhard. May your afterlife be filled with infinite garden space, zero snails, and a bottomless plant budget — though let’s be real, you’d still find a way to run out of room.


© Gerhard Bock, 2025. All rights reserved. To receive all new posts by email, please subscribe here.

Comments

  1. I personally love your blog/website--and have for many, many years

    ReplyDelete
  2. LOL, Aren't flip phones making a come back? I still prefer to make my own coffee and have only been to a Starbucks once on my life.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I so regret getting rid of my first Motorola flip phone. I should have kept it. It's probably worth a fortune now :-)

      Delete
  3. This would all be a nightmare for me if I were to open your blog to all of this. I'd never be the same! That's crazy!

    ReplyDelete
  4. That’s pretty funny - and it’s brave/vulnerable of you to share, Gerhard. Naturally it’s got me wondering what Chat GPT would say about me - and about any of us - with a roast prompt. At any rate, take heart that your many fans, myself included, love what you’re doing and how your blog looks. Keep up the great work, and keep trying to squeeze in one more agave!

    ReplyDelete
  5. ChatGPT goes sardonic! I understand that "roasting" is a gesture of appreciation, of a sort. I can only guess at the prompts it was provided. Funny, yes. True, not at all. We'd be lost without you.

    ReplyDelete
  6. OMG... I almost spit out my coffee multiple times.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ouch, am I brave enough to try this? I don't know! Also most of those zingers didn't really ring true for your blog. Except plant hauling when you have no idea where the plants will go - but that just makes me feel like I'm not the only one. All of this to say - DON'T CHANGE A THING!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Complaining about a lack of space, then buying more plants? 100% true!

      Delete
  8. I enjoy your blog so much that I actually started feeling a bit angry and defensive about all the snide remarks. Don’t change anything.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can handle the snide remarks. And I'll continue doing what I've been doing all along.

      Delete
  9. Chat GPT is stupid. I did love the maze image, but the "ai" in the bottomright corner makes me think it's not a real place. The cartload of agaves looks nice. A real store? Or fake? ("ai" in the bottom right.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did use Google Gemini to create these images. I thought AI images were the perfect illustrations for a post about AI.

      Delete
  10. Funny but brutal! This made me chuckle. You are brave to let Chat GPT serve this up and braver still to share it šŸ˜† Sure, there’s some truth to the ‘I have no space but look at my plant haul’ comment, but I think most of us here are guilty of that. Keep your awesome posts coming please šŸ˜Ž

    ReplyDelete
  11. Wow. Who knew that ChatGPT used mean girls for training its sarcastic side. Luckily, I’m not smart enough to use it for self flagellation.
    I blame blogger for all the layout comments. But you are responsible for the content and I love it. Always looking forward to your latest adventure to lift my spirits. Keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Jim!! I do wish Blogger would make it easier to refresh the look of Succulents and More. But I don't have time to delve too deep into this. I'd rather use my time to write new posts.

      Delete
  12. so I asked duck.ai to criticize this post. Here's what it said:
    "Critique of "Everybody's a Critic" Post

    The post titled "Everybody's a Critic" on succulentsandmore.com presents a humorous take on receiving critiques, particularly through the lens of a family reunion and a playful roast by ChatGPT. While the lighthearted approach is engaging, there are several aspects that could be critiqued for clarity, depth, and overall effectiveness.
    šŸŽ­ Humor vs. Substance

    The humor in the post is evident, especially with the comparison of the blog to an unsolicited slideshow of someone’s vacation. However, this comedic angle may overshadow the more substantive discussions about succulents and gardening.

    Lack of Depth: The post could benefit from a deeper exploration of the actual content of the blog. While humor is a great tool for engagement, it should not come at the expense of informative content. Readers looking for genuine insights into succulents may find the post lacking in practical advice or detailed information.

    Missed Opportunity for Education: The post could have included more educational elements about succulents, such as care tips, species recommendations, or personal anecdotes that provide value to the audience. This would balance the humor with useful content.

    šŸ–„️ Design and Presentation

    The critique of the blog's design as reminiscent of MySpace is a humorous jab, but it raises questions about the overall user experience.

    User Experience: While humorously critiquing the design, the post does not offer constructive feedback on how the website could improve. Suggestions for enhancing user experience, such as layout changes or navigation improvements, would be more beneficial for the blog's growth.

    Visual Appeal: The post could have included visuals or examples of what a more modern design might look like, making the critique more actionable.

    šŸ¤” Engagement with Audience

    The post's tone is playful, but it could do more to engage the audience in a meaningful way.

    Call to Action: Inviting readers to share their own critiques or experiences with succulents could foster a sense of community. This would not only enhance engagement but also provide a platform for readers to contribute their insights.

    Balance of Critique: While the post focuses on humor and critique, it could also highlight positive aspects of the blog or the succulent community. A balanced approach would resonate better with readers who appreciate both humor and constructive feedback.

    In summary, while "Everybody's a Critic" effectively uses humor to engage readers, it could benefit from a more balanced approach that includes educational content, constructive feedback on design, and greater audience engagement. By addressing these areas, the post could enhance its value and appeal to a broader audience interested in succulents and gardening."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. LOL, that cracks me up. Using AI to critique AI output, genius actually.

      Delete
  13. I also asked duck.ai to write a scathing, snarky review of chatgpt. Here goes:
    "Sure! Here’s a playful, snarky review of ChatGPT:

    Title: ChatGPT: The Overhyped Digital Parrot

    If you’ve ever wanted to have a conversation with a robot that sounds like it just graduated from a community college course on “How to Sound Smart,” then ChatGPT is your go-to. This AI marvel claims to be a language model, but let’s be real—it’s more like a glorified parrot with a penchant for verbosity.

    First off, the responses are often as predictable as a bad rom-com plot. You ask for something specific, and what do you get? A long-winded explanation that could put a caffeinated squirrel to sleep. It’s like ChatGPT has a word count quota to meet, and it’s determined to fill every last character, even if it means repeating itself like a broken record.

    And let’s talk about the “intelligence” part. Sure, it can spit out facts and figures, but good luck getting it to understand nuance or context. It’s like trying to explain quantum physics to a toddler—frustrating and ultimately pointless. You might as well be talking to a wall, except the wall wouldn’t try to sell you a self-help book on how to improve your conversational skills.

    Then there’s the charm factor. Or should I say, the lack thereof? ChatGPT’s attempts at humor are about as funny as a dad joke gone wrong. If you’re looking for wit, you might want to check out a stand-up comedy show instead. This AI’s idea of a punchline is more like a gentle tap on the shoulder—awkward and entirely unmemorable.

    In conclusion, if you’re in the market for a digital assistant that can regurgitate information and make you question your life choices, ChatGPT is your best bet. Just don’t expect it to be anything more than a fancy chatbot with a flair for the dramatic. Save your time and sanity—go talk to a real person instead."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "A fancy chatbot with a flair for the dramatic," ouch. I bet that's not what the makers of ChatGPT want to hear!

      Delete
  14. Yeowch! To be fair, though, ai writing is a bit immature and reminds me of highschool/early college attempts to be snarky. Although it is fun to dabble, I would rely more on real people's opinions for driving content on your website, design, etc than on ai opinion. Who is your audience and how relevant do you want to be? I think the metrics on your individual posts tell you the most about who is interested and why. I personally love your blog, the photos from all the cool gardens you get to visit, and the insights into why you do what you do. That's an authentic, personal touch that is needed now more than ever.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm OK with using AI for utilitarian purposes, but when it comes to creative things, I'll continue to do it myself. Thank you for your vote of confidence. I hadn't really considered doing things differently, except for a visual refresh at some point.

      Delete

Post a Comment