Removing a VW Beetle-sized Agave ‘Silver Surfer’ in Michele's garden

We’ve all heard of puppies who turn into adult dogs that are much larger than the owner had ever expected. The same can happen with agaves, as you’ll see in this post.

In April 2009, my friend Michele, whose garden is featured in this post, bought a couple of agaves from Cistus Nursery on Sauvie Island near Portland, OR. One was an Agave gentryi ‘Jaws’, the other a new introduction called ‘Silver Surfer’. Both were cute and small, no larger than 4 × 4 inches. Michele still has the original tag:

Cistus tag for Agave ‘Silver Surfer’

Agave ‘Silver Surfer’ was introduced by Plant Delights Nursery in 2007, two years before Michele bought hers. The original source was a seedling from a 1992 Yucca Do Nursery seed collecting expedition (YD 45-83) at 5,200’ ft. above Palmillas, Tamaulipas, Mexico. There, Agave americana ssp. protamericana intergrades with Agave asperrima (formerly known as Agave scabra).

The Cistus tag gave the size as “at least” 4 × 5 ft. That’s what Michele went by when she bought her ‘Silver Surfer’. At that time, though, ‘Silver Surfer’ had been around for less than 10 years and nobody really knew what its mature size would be under garden conditions...

By September 2010 (see photo below), Michele’s ‘Silver Surfer’ had tripled in size to about 1 ft.:

Agave ‘Silver Surfer’ in September 2010, 18 months after purchase

By March 2013, two and half years later, it had grown to over 2 × 3 ft.:

Agave ‘Silver Surfer’ (left) in March 2013, Agave vilmoriana on the right (now long gone)

By September 2018, it was taller than the 5 ft. fence behind it:

Agave ‘Silver Surfer’ in September 2018: 5 × 5 ft.

And here it is in January 2023, 7 ft. tall by 12 ft. wide:

Agave ‘Silver Surfer’ in January 2023: 7 × 12 ft.

Yes, you read right. By January 2023, it had grown to 7 × 12 ft. That’s quite a bit larger than Cistus’ original estimate of 4 × 5 ft. (OK, they did say “at least”).

Michele was getting more concerned about this puppy turned into Great Dane. It was only going to get larger and would eventually produce a flower stalk of immense height and weight. Removing the bloomed out carcass would have been a gargantuan task.

For these reasons, Michele made the difficult decision to have ‘Silver Surfer’ removed now. Fortunately, the landscaper who works for her homeowner’s association agreed to slay the monster. Michele documented the progress in these photos:

Leaves removed, leaving a massive (and heeeeeeavy) “pineapple”

Cutting up the core with a chainsaw

Look at the orange ellipsis in this photo: it’s a stream of liquid shooting out of the core. Michele says it was an impressive sight.

Whittling away at the core until it was all chopped up

Michele’s landscaper took the remains of ‘Silver Surfer’ to the county landfill for composting. He and Michele were stunned by the weight of his load: almost 2000 pounds! Michele thinks the core weighed about 600, and each leaf (taken off at the beginning of the job) an average of 20 pounds. Michele estimates there had been at least 50 leaves. These are staggering weights. But then, ‘Silver Surfer’ had been bigger than a VW Beetle!

In the photo below, which I took in June 2022, you can see an Agave ovatifolia between ‘Silver Surfer’ on the left and ‘Jaws’ (also from Cistus) on the right. A. ovatifolia is not a small agave, yet it’s completely dwarfed by the other two:


Here’s Agave ovatifolia, now that ‘Silver Surfer’ is gone:

Agave ovatifolia, suddenly a focal point in this corner of Michele’s garden

Michele also took this opportunity to remove the Agave americana ‘Mediopicta Alba’ to the right of A. ovatifolia to create more space between A. ovatifolia and A. gentryi ‘Jaws.’ It was easy to do using her landscaper’s sharp-end shovel and pickaxe. Michele saved the pups to share with friends but may keep one for herself.

The next step is for Michele to remove the remaining ‘Silver Surfer’ roots and runners and then rebuild the area with gravel, soil and rocks to make it ready for replanting. I look forward to seeing what she ends up choosing.

Removing a plant that has been with you for 14 years and has occupied such a large part of your garden (literally) isn’t easy, but Michele made the right decision. ‘Silver Surfer’ would be fantastic in a larger garden; in fact, it reminded me of the Agave franzosinii specimens at the Ruth Bancroft Garden. In Michele’s small garden, however, it was simply too massive.

Michele says that she would never have bought ‘Silver Surfer’ if she had known what its eventual size would be. At the same time, it’s hard to blame Cistus for underestimating the dimensions, considering this information simply wasn’t known at the time. That’s just how it goes sometimes, especially with new introductions.

Except for the second to last, all photos in this post are Michele’s.


© Gerhard Bock, 2023. All rights reserved. To receive all new posts by email, please subscribe here.

Comments

  1. That's a lesson in caution about new introductions to be sure! Even when I have a sense of the mature size of a plant, I've a nasty tendency to crowd plants during their infancy, which results in problems downstream. It doesn't help when the growers themselves either don't have the experience with particular plant to estimate its size, or they use conservative estimates like its size at "maturity" (e.g. 5 years out) on their tags. 'Silver Surfer' is undeniably an attractive plant but anything with Agave americana in its parentage tends to scare me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I now take the size and hardiness info on plant labels with a grain of salt. More often that not, they're only rough approximations. Plus, every situation is slightly different.

      The only americana variety I wouldn't hesitate to plant is 'Cornelius' because it does stay under 2 ft.

      Delete
  2. What a beast ! Michele made the right choice -if for no other reason than to bring Agave ovatifolia out of hiding. And she'll have a nice big footprint to replant. I thought about the franzosinii clump at RBG too .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Every time I see those Agave franzosinii, I marvel at their size!

      Delete
  3. Beautiful plants, but it sounds like it was the best decision. New plantings will be interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don't know if I could have removed such a beautiful agave without seeing it through to the natural end. But I understand each gardener has to decide what's worth keeping, and removal is a necessary part of gardening. So cool to document the growth of this stunning monster though, and how much it weighed by the end. Wow!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Michele had been going back and forth on whether to remove it or not, so no easy decision. But considering how unbalanced this massive hulk made her garden look, it was the right thing to do.

      Delete
  5. It's a wonder the fence didn't heave near the huge Agave. I have Agave gentryi 'Jaws' in my front garden. I had no idea of the size when I planted it. Luckily it is in a good spot out of the way of other plants! Michele is lucky to have a landscaper to do such a job!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I wonder how far out the roots extended!

      I have a 'Jaws' also and it's almost mature. Fortunately, it's out of the way enough not to cause any bodily harm. It does pup.

      Yes, Michele is very lucky to have her landscaper do the hard work. It sounds like he, too, was surprised by the amount of effort required. But then, this wasn't your ordinary agave!

      Delete
  6. Okay first of all, why isn't that guy wearing eye protection!? Secondly, like Pam says, I don't know that I could have removed such a beautiful agave. I remember thinking my in-laws were crazy to have removed every agave from their garden in New Mexico because they didn't want to deal with the removal after they bloomed someday. Then again, I (most likely) won't ever have to deal with an agave of that size. As for plant labels and sizes (and I realize you know this, but I'm going to say it anyway) there's the size a particular plant will get in "most" gardens, and then there's the size it will get in the perfect situation. We deal with a lot of too small label descriptions here in the PNW where some plants are so happy they double the stated size. Of course none of them are Agave 'Silver Surfer'... I don't think I've seen any up here that even came close to the stated 4 x 5ft.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, eye protection would have been sensible, esp. since agave juices are an irritant.

      Does John Kuzma still have his 'Silver Surfer'?

      Delete
    2. Yes, but they were heavily damaged with our December storm.

      Delete
    3. Darn. They probably get set back regularly by the Portland winters, which is why they don't get as back as Michele's.

      Delete
  7. Wow and wow! In a way it was quite sad Silver Surfer had to go as it was truly spectacular. However, considering it was a mere teenager Michelle mad the right decision. Has Cistus been advised to revise their size estimates?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Ann at Cistus saw my post and said she'd correct their database. I don't think Cistus carries 'Silver Surfer' anymore. In fact, I'm not sure anybody does.

      Delete
  8. I've got a medio-picta that is huge and needs to be taken out of the xeriscape bed at the college I volunteer at, but I am allergic to the sap and am dreading the job. I'll have poison oak-like symptoms wherever the sap touches me. I've yet to dig up an agave without getting 'sapped' no matter how careful I am. I also have a desmettiana that's blooming at the high school I volunteer at, and while smaller than the other one, it's still not going to be fun to remove, sigh.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When my desmetiana bloomed, I left it in place long enough for the bulbils to put on some size. By that point, the rosette had died and I was able to simply pull it out by the flower stalk.

      Delete

Post a Comment