Time to Preen

This fall, we’ve had rain on three separate occasions thus far, totally just a smidge over 1". That isn’t much in the grand scheme of things, but it’s enough for this to happen:

Front yard a few blocks away

Yep, weeds are sprouting enthusiastically, and it’s just the beginning.

In our front yard a few days ago

I admit, shamefacedly, that I let things get out of control this past spring:

April 2023

I ended up spending a lot of time pulling weeds when I could have prevented them (or at least most of them) in the first place.

This year I will be more proactive. I’ve had great results using a product called Preen Extended Control in cactus pots, and I plan on applying it on a larger scale to prevent weeds from sprouting in other areas where they aren’t wanted. Which, technically, is everywhere since they’re never wanted, haha.






Preen is a pre-emergent herbicide that prevents seeds from germinating. It’s not selective – it works on flower seeds just as effectively as it does on weed seeds. Weed suppression is achieved using corn gluten meal, a byproduct of corn milling. Depending on the product (Preen Extended Control, regular Preen, or Preen Natural), the amount of corn gluten meal ranges from 98% to 100% percent. Preen Natural is 100% corn gluten meal, regular Preen adds one herbicide (trifluralin) and Preen Extended Control two (trifluralin and isoxaben).

Corn gluten meal is harmless (it’s also used in animal feed) and quite effective at suppressing weeds. It technically doesn’t prevent weeds from germinating, but it stops the germinating seeds from forming roots. The end result is the same. Here is a more in-depth discussion of corn meal gluten as a weed preventer.

The difference between the three Preen products is how often they need to be applied: Preen Natural (100% corn gluten meal) needs to be applied once a month, regular Preen (containing trifluralin) every three months. Preen Extended Control (containing two herbicides) is good for six months.

I don’t want to go into the complex issues surrounding the use of herbicides. Whether you use them or not is a personal decision. In an ideal world, we wouldn’t use herbicides, because an ideal world wouldn’t have weeds in the first place.

Some people find weeding therapeutic. For me, it’s my least favorite chore. Because I want as little work as possible, I use Preen Extended Control. I’m aware that it may be harmful to the environment, like any weed control product. I use as little of it as I can to keep my garden reasonably weed-free. Because I really don’t want to see this again:


I should add that Preen doesn't work on weeds that have already sprouted. In fact, since it's about 10% nitrogen by weight, it gives them an extra boost. It's best to get rid of existing weeds first before applying Preen.

Note: Some readers got the impression that this post is a paid advertisement for Preen. Far from it; it's simply my personal experience. I've never been paid to promote a commercial product. And if it ever happened, I would be very clear about it. Transparency and honesty are very important to me.


© Gerhard Bock, 2023. All rights reserved. To receive all new posts by email, please subscribe here.

Comments

  1. I like the idea of using the weed control products in pots - there's nothing more annoying than trying to get weeds out of a pot with spikes. It would probably be useful in my succulent beds too, where the blasted bermuda grass keeps coming back. I just wish there was an easy way to get rid of spotted spurge growing up in the middle of my creeping thyme :(

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Spotted spurge, that's my #2 nemesis. #1 is oxalis. I feel fortunate I've never had to deal with bermuda grass--that's on another level altogether.

      Delete
  2. I appreciate someone who’s forthright about their controversial decision.
    Thanks for the breakdown on the Preen offerings. I think this is entirely reasonable for anyone who nurtures a spiky garden.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm learning to be better at preventing problems instead of having to deal with them later on.

      Delete
  3. Replies
    1. I see why you might have gotten that impression, but no, it's simply my personal experience (and the result of some research I did). I didn't get paid to promote Preen. If I had, I would have made that clear.

      Delete
  4. With the many spiky and downright dangerous plants in your garden I can see why weeds are more of a challenge than in an average garden. The soil is the Earth's biggest seed depository so always an ongoing issue especially when some got to go to seed. I wish you luck.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What you said about soil being a massive seed depository is so true. I think that's why that red gomphrena came back this year--I removed an aloe and must have disturbed the soil enough to bring buried gomphrena seed to the surface.

      Delete
  5. I don't look forward to weeding either, right up there with mowing. Mowing was an easier obstacle to rid of!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think mowing is easier because you keep the grass under control if you do it regularly. But I guess the same could be said about weeding...

      Delete
  6. Yes, the weeds have just exploded up out of the earth with the onset of our rains this fall. It is hard to have a fair sized garden without using herbicide. And, unless you are rich enough to have a small army of weeding minions, there just isn't enough time in a day to keep them down. The weeds get away from me every year. I should get out there and weed right now in the rain...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. More rain in the forecast for this week. That means more weeds :-(

      Delete
    2. I'm one of those people who actually enjoys weeding. And now that I'm retired I can keep up with it better. That damnable shotweed is rearing it's head but the ground is still too wet from the last rain to pull effectively so I'm using my winged weeder to scuff it up. I usually weed with my hori-hori and my cobra while sitting on the ground. It gives me a plants eye view of the garden !

      Delete
  7. Regular preen user here. I put it (extended weed control) down on my entire garden (3/4 acre) every October and it gets me through rainy season seed free

    ReplyDelete
  8. How much preen do you use in pots? I would love to lower my weeding chore and have thought about trying preen, but am afraid it might stunt root growth. Do you measure out an amount, or just sprinkle some over the soil without measuring?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment