Thursday, July 19, 2012

Still battling Bradford pear tree suckers

2½ years ago, we had a Bradford pear tree removed in our front yard because of severe mistletoe infestation that was causing limbs to break off. We replaced the tree with the giant clumping timber bamboo (Bambusa oldhamii) that has become the focal point of the front yard. Read this post for more information about this transformation.

The stump of the Bradford pear was ground out to a depth of approx. 2 feet—enough you would think to get rid of the tree for good. While that might be true for most trees, it clearly wasn’t enough to kill this one. Suckers started to pop up almost immediately, not only near the stump but many feet away.

120715_Bradford_pear_suckers3
 

My default method of control is to cut out the suckers with a hori-hori knife. In April 2011 I tried a product called Sucker Stopper RTU and while it may have slowed down sucker production for a while, it ultimately didn’t work. 

As you can see in these photos, there are so many suckers, I sometimes don’t even know where to begin.

120715_Bradford_pear_suckers1
 

Last weekend I cut out all the suckers I was able to spot—not always easy considering how many plants there are within 15 ft. of the where the tree had originally been.

120715_Bradford_pear_suckers2
 

The result is very satisfying.

120715_Bradford_pear_suckers_gone2
 

No suckers, just stuff I planted, like these yellow-flowering pokers (Kniphofia citrina?)

120715_Bradford_pear_suckers_gone1
 

Unfortunately, within a week or two the suckers will make a comeback. How much energy could possibly be stored in the remaining tree roots to still produce so many suckers???

Which brings me to the point of this post: Does anybody have any suggestions on how to eliminate these suckers once and for all? Would cutting the suckers near ground level and painting the cut surface with full-strength Roundup (glyphosate) work? I hate using chemicals in the garden but I’m running out of patience.

6 comments:

  1. Replies
    1. Nope. But wouldn't they eat the roots of desirable plants as well, including my Bambusa oldhamii that's right there?

      Delete
    2. I have at least one resident gopher (little bastard), despite already...dispatching...one earlier this year. So far, he hasn't touched any of the 7 bamboos that surround my back lawn, where he hangs out. He seems to love grass and sedges, but ignores my clover.

      But, yeah, I'm sure he'd eat all sorts of stuff you don't want him to. I'm jealous of your lack of gophers!

      Delete
  2. If you can pull them (using a shovel helps) they seem to stay away longer. I've heard that painting "Brush be Gone" (Triclopyr amine) directly on the fresh cut before it has a chance to heal over is effective but haven't tried it myself. How frustrating!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, that's why I try to cut out as much as possible with my weeding knife.

      I haven't tried Brush-B-Gon but it's an excellent suggestion. Based on your reply I did a quick Google search and found this encouraging blurb. The writer's quip about Bradford pear root stock having "more lives than Regis Philbin" made me laugh.

      Delete
  3. Round-up works best on foliage. It is carried down into the plant's vascular system which it then blocks. I would carefully paint each un-cut sucker with round up diluted according to package directions. I can sympathize, because I've been pulling out Wisteria suckers since I pulled the Wisteria out in 2008.

    Bamboo sure looks nice there.

    ReplyDelete